Cave Creek homes over $1.5 million: prices, supply, and how many actually sell

Your vision, your home, our expertise.

Of the Cave Creek homes listed at $1.5 million or more that left the market over the past year, only about half actually sold. Our Cave Creek luxury homes for sale page counts 90 closings and 85 listings that were cancelled or expired in the 12 months ending November 14, 2026. That 51% listing success rate, next to 8.7 months of supply, tells you more about this tier than the median price does.

The short answer Cave Creek homes at $1.5 million and up sold at a median of $1,950,000, or $471 per square foot, over the 12 months ending November 14, 2026. With 65 for sale and about 8.7 months of supply, the segment leans toward buyers, and only 51% of listings that left the market closed. Pricing against the right comparable sales matters more here than anywhere else in town.

What the data says

  • Median sale price, $1.5M and up: $1,950,000, or $471 per square foot, on 90 sales (Arizona Luxury Partners Cave Creek luxury homes page, ARMLS data, Nov 14, 2025 to Nov 14, 2026)
  • For sale today: 65 homes, median list price $2,199,000, about 8.7 months of supply (same page, as of Nov 14, 2026)
  • Listing success rate: 51%, with 90 closed and 85 cancelled or expired (same page, 12 months to Nov 14, 2026)
  • Time and price: 80.5 median cumulative days on market, 96.54% of final list price, 95.24% of original list price (same page)
  • Top of the tier: 11 of the 90 sales, or 12%, closed at $3 million or more; the highest sale was $5,496,000 (same page)
  • All Cave Creek homes, for context: 616 sales at a median of $869,750, $357 per square foot, 4.5 months of supply, 67% listing success rate (Arizona Luxury Partners Cave Creek homes page, 12 months to Nov 18, 2026)

What it means

The gap between asking and selling is the first thing to notice. The median list price of homes for sale today is $2,199,000, while the median sale over the past year was $1,950,000. That is a $249,000 difference, or about 12.8% of the sale median, calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners. Part of that is mix, since the most expensive listings take longest to sell and pile up in the active count. Part of it is simply that many sellers start above what the market has been paying.

Supply confirms it. At 8.7 months, the luxury tier has nearly twice the supply of Cave Creek homes for sale overall, where the November 18 figure was about 4.5 months. And 26 of the 65 luxury listings had already cut their price by November 14.

Price per square foot runs higher at the top. The tier's $471 median compares with $357 for all Cave Creek sales, about 32% higher, calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners from the two pages (their 12 month windows end four days apart). The median luxury home that sold was about 4,025 square feet.

Values have been steady rather than climbing. The yearly median for the tier rose from $1,595,000 in 2016 to $1,950,000 in 2025, up 22%, and peaked at $2,020,000 in 2020. Through November 14, the 2026 median was $1,925,000, about 1.3% below 2025, calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners.

How Carefree's high end compares

Next door, Carefree homes for sale sold at a median of $1,075,000 over the 12 months ending November 18, 2026, and 74 of the 133 sales, or 56%, closed at $1 million or more. Carefree's listing success rate was 62%, with about 4.8 months of supply. The figures for homes for sale in Carefree 85377 as of November 19 are close: 132 sales at a median of $1,064,813 and about 4.7 months of supply.

Within Carefree, The Boulders homes for sale closed 41 sales at a median of $1,450,000, or $500 per square foot, with 12 listed at a median of $2,099,500 and about 3.5 months of supply as of November 18. Desert Forest homes for sale is a much smaller sample: 5 sales at a median of $1,258,000 and 1 home listed on November 18.

On the Cave Creek side, most luxury sales carry a Cave Creek 85331 address, where 612 homes of all prices sold at a median of $869,250 in the 12 months to November 19. See where Cave Creek and Carefree sit on our Northeast Valley map, which has a Cave Creek and Carefree zoom area.

Practical advice

If you are buying

  • Compare by setting, not by town. A hillside custom home on acreage, a home in a golf community, and a horse property can all sit above $1.5 million and trade on very different terms. Ask for sales with the same lot type, age, and setting.
  • Look at cumulative days on market. The median sale took 80.5 cumulative days, and many listings have been relisted. A home that has been for sale through a cancellation and a relist may have more room to negotiate than its current listing date suggests.
  • Check the price history. With 26 of 65 listings already reduced, the original list price tells you how the seller first read the market and how far they have moved.
  • Confirm the basics early. Jurisdiction, water source, septic, road maintenance, and permits matter at this price. The 85331 ZIP code includes Tatum Ranch, which is in the City of Phoenix, and unincorporated county land.

If you are selling

  • Price to the sales, not to the actives. The median list price is about $249,000 above the median sale. Competing listings show what sellers hope for; closed sales show what buyers paid.
  • Plan for a longer timeline. With 8.7 months of supply, buyers have choices. Have the well, septic, permit, and HOA records ready before the first showing.
  • Watch the first few weeks. If showings are thin early, adjust sooner rather than becoming one of the 85 listings that expired or were pulled.

Avoid this mistake: pricing a $1.5 million plus home off the Cave Creek town median or off a neighbor's asking price. The town median is $869,750 and covers very different homes, and asking prices in this tier run well above closed prices.

The honest caveats

Ninety sales in a year is a small sample, and a handful of large estates can move the median. The luxury figures run through November 14 and the town and Carefree figures through November 18 or 19, so comparisons between them are approximate. Cave Creek here means the MLS city, which follows the mailing address, not the town limits. Listing success rates count a listing that was cancelled and relisted as cancelled, which can make the rate look lower for homes that eventually sold. Desert Forest's figures rest on 5 sales and should be read as a snapshot, not a trend. Your home's value depends on its own lot, views, condition, and setting.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a luxury home cost in Cave Creek?

Over the 12 months ending November 14, 2026, the 90 Cave Creek homes that sold for $1.5 million or more closed at a median of $1,950,000, or $471 per square foot. Sale prices ran from $1,500,000 to $5,496,000. The median list price of the 65 homes for sale on November 14 was $2,199,000.

How many Cave Creek homes over $1.5 million are for sale right now?

Our Cave Creek luxury homes page counted 65 homes listed at $1.5 million and up on November 14, 2026. List prices ran from $1,500,000 to $11,500,000, and 26 of the 65 had already had a price change.

Is the Cave Creek luxury market a buyer's market?

At about 8.7 months of supply, the $1.5 million and up segment leans toward buyers. That compares with about 4.5 months for all Cave Creek homes as of November 18, 2026, which is close to balanced. Supply varies a lot by setting and price, so check the numbers for the specific type of home you want.

How long do luxury homes take to sell in Cave Creek?

The median was 80.5 cumulative days on market for Cave Creek homes that sold at $1.5 million or more in the 12 months ending November 14, 2026. Cumulative days count earlier listings of the same home that were cancelled or expired before it was relisted, so a home's current listing date can understate how long it has really been for sale.

What share of Cave Creek luxury listings actually sell?

The listing success rate was 51% for the $1.5 million and up segment: 90 listings closed and 85 were cancelled or expired over the 12 months ending November 14, 2026. For all Cave Creek homes the rate was 67% over the 12 months ending November 18, 2026.

How much below asking do Cave Creek luxury homes sell?

The median sale closed at 96.54% of the final list price and 95.24% of the original list price. On a home first listed at $2,000,000, a 95.24% outcome would be about $95,200 below the original asking price, calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners. Individual results vary widely.

Do Cave Creek luxury sellers pay buyer concessions?

16% of Cave Creek sales at $1.5 million and up included a seller concession, with a median of $10,000 among the sales that had one. Concessions are seller paid buyer costs, such as closing costs or a rate buydown, as reported on the closed MLS record.

Have Cave Creek luxury home prices gone up?

The yearly median for Cave Creek homes that sold at $1.5 million or more went from $1,595,000 in 2016 to $1,950,000 in 2025, up 22%. The peak yearly median was $2,020,000 in 2020, and the 2026 median through November 14 was $1,925,000. A median moves with the mix of homes that sold, not just with values.

How does Carefree compare with Cave Creek at the high end?

Carefree's overall median sale price was $1,075,000 over the 12 months ending November 18, 2026, and 56% of its 133 sales closed at $1 million or more. In The Boulders, 41 homes sold at a median of $1,450,000, or $500 per square foot. Carefree's overall listing success rate was 62% with about 4.8 months of supply.

Is a Cave Creek mailing address always in the Town of Cave Creek?

No. The 85331 ZIP code also covers Tatum Ranch, which is in the City of Phoenix, and parts of unincorporated Maricopa County. Confirm the jurisdiction, water source, septic system, and road maintenance for any property before you write an offer.

The bottom line

Cave Creek's $1.5 million and up segment is steady on price but slow on pace. The median sale has held near $1.95 million, supply sits near 8.7 months, and about half the listings that left the market did not sell. Buyers have room to negotiate with good data in hand. Sellers who price to closed sales, not to hopeful listings, give themselves the best chance to be in the half that closes.

Read more: Fountain Hills homes over $1.5 million: prices, supply, and where they sell · Cave Creek 85331 home sales through October 2026: what the numbers show

Thinking about buying or selling in Cave Creek?

White-glove service at every price point.

Book a Call Get My Home Value

Browse homes: Cave Creek luxury homes for sale · Cave Creek homes for sale · The Boulders homes for sale · Carefree homes for sale

Related: Explore the Northeast Valley map · See our recently sold properties · More market insights

Your advisors

Kyle Hermann
Associate Broker | Realtor®
602.814.7266
kyle@azluxurypartners.com
License BR665419000
Meet Kyle

Cheryl Solano
CRS® | Realtor®
480.518.0181
cheryl@azluxurypartners.com
License SA541911000
Meet Cheryl

Art Buck
Associate Broker | Realtor® | CCIM
480.510.7689
art@azluxurypartners.com
License BR014102000
Meet Art

Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties

Sources

  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Cave Creek luxury homes for sale ($1.5 million and up), ARMLS via Flexmls closed sales November 14, 2025 to November 14, 2026, active listings November 14, 2026, and yearly medians 2016 to 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Cave Creek homes for sale, ARMLS via Flexmls closed sales November 18, 2025 to November 18, 2026, and active listings November 18, 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Cave Creek 85331 homes for sale, ARMLS via Flexmls, 12 months to November 19, 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Carefree homes for sale, ARMLS via Flexmls closed sales November 18, 2025 to November 18, 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Carefree 85377 homes for sale, ARMLS via Flexmls, 12 months to November 19, 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, The Boulders homes for sale and Desert Forest homes for sale, ARMLS via Flexmls, 12 months to November 18, 2026; accessed November 19, 2026. Link
  • List to sale gap calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: $2,199,000 median list minus $1,950,000 median sale equals $249,000, or 12.8% of the sale median.
  • Price per square foot difference calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: $471 luxury median vs. $357 town median, about 32% higher.
  • 2026 vs. 2025 change calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: $1,925,000 year to date vs. $1,950,000 in 2025, about 1.3% lower.
  • Below asking example calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: $2,000,000 original list price times (1 minus 0.9524) equals about $95,200.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This article is for general information only and is not financial, lending, legal, or tax advice. Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties, 21020 N. Pima Road, Scottsdale, AZ 85255. Brokerage License LC629808000. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Previous
Previous

Trilogy at Verde River: new home prices, plans, and the golf resale market in Rio Verde

Next
Next

Scottsdale short-term rental rules: the license, taxes, and penalties before you buy