Cave Creek vs. Carefree: home prices, market pace, and town basics compared

Your vision, your home, our expertise.

Cave Creek and Carefree share a border, a school district, and Black Mountain, and over the past ten years their median home prices rose by almost exactly the same amount: about 96% in each town. What separates them today is price level, pace, and the kind of property you are likely to find. Over the 12 months through November 16, 2026, the median sale was $870,000 with a Cave Creek address and $1,099,000 with a Carefree address, and Cave Creek sold about 4.6 homes for every one in Carefree. Here is how the two towns compare side by side, using the market figures on our own city and ZIP pages and official public sources.

The short answer

Carefree costs more and moves slower. Over the past 12 months the median Carefree sale was $1,099,000 ($388 per square foot, 98 days on market) versus $870,000 in Cave Creek ($357 per square foot, 61 days), per our ARMLS based city pages as of November 16, 2026. Cave Creek is the larger town, about 37.7 square miles, with far more sales and a wider mix of acreage, horse properties, and subdivisions. Carefree is about 8.8 square miles of mostly custom homes on desert lots plus golf and resort area properties.

What the data says

  • Median sale price, past 12 months: Cave Creek $870,000 on 614 sales; Carefree $1,099,000 on 133 sales (Arizona Luxury Partners city pages, ARMLS via Flexmls, Nov 16, 2025 to Nov 16, 2026)
  • Price per square foot: Cave Creek $357; Carefree $388 (same pages, same period)
  • Median cumulative days on market: Cave Creek 61 days; Carefree 98 days (same pages, same period)
  • Sale to original list price: Cave Creek 96.07%; Carefree 92.89% (same pages, same period)
  • Listing success rate: Cave Creek 68% (614 closed, 294 cancelled or expired); Carefree 62% (133 closed, 83 cancelled or expired) (same pages, same period)
  • Supply today: Cave Creek 239 listed, median list $972,500, about 4.7 months; Carefree 50 listed, median list $1,122,500, about 4.5 months (same pages, as of Nov 16, 2026)
  • Ten year change in yearly median: Cave Creek $420,000 (2016) to $825,000 (2025); Carefree $591,250 (2016) to $1,160,625 (2025); both up 96% (same pages, yearly medians)

The two towns at a glance

Cave Creek was settled in 1870 and incorporated in 1986. Carefree was planned in the mid 1950s by K.T. Palmer and Tom Darlington as a master planned community, with land sales starting in 1955, and it incorporated in 1984. Black Mountain, at 3,398 feet, sits on the line between them. See how they fit together in the Cave Creek and Carefree zoom area on our Northeast Valley map.

  • Size: Cave Creek covers about 37.71 square miles of land; Carefree about 8.81. Cave Creek is roughly 4.3 times larger by land area (calculated).
  • Population: about 5,160 in Cave Creek and 3,600 in Carefree, per the 2025 Census estimates shown on our city pages.
  • Schools: Carefree is served by Cave Creek Unified. Cave Creek is served by Cave Creek Unified and, in its western portion, Deer Valley Unified. Confirm the district for any specific address with the district.
  • Sales tax: both towns levy a 3.00% retail rate on top of the 6.30% state and Maricopa County rate, about 9.30% combined (calculated). On food for home consumption the town rate is 3.00% in Cave Creek and 2.00% in Carefree, per the Arizona Department of Revenue rate table effective November 1, 2026.

Homes and price points

Browse Cave Creek homes for sale and you will see mostly custom homes on acreage, including horse properties, along with planned subdivisions. Keep in mind that many homes with a Cave Creek mailing address sit outside the town limits, including parts of the City of Phoenix. That is why the city page and the Cave Creek 85331 homes for sale page show the same 614 sales.

Carefree homes for sale are mostly custom homes on desert lots, plus golf course and resort area properties. The homes for sale in 85377 page shows the same 133 sales and $1,099,000 median.

The price gap is real but narrower per square foot than per home. The Carefree median sale is $229,000, or about 26.3%, above Cave Creek's, while price per square foot is only $31, or about 8.7%, higher (calculated). Part of the difference is size: the median home sold in Carefree was 2,799 square feet versus 2,523 in Cave Creek, about 10.9% larger. In Carefree, 56% of sales closed at $1 million or more, versus 40% in Cave Creek.

Communities that show the range

Market pace: where homes sell faster

Cave Creek is the busier market, at about 51 sales a month versus about 11 in Carefree. Homes there also moved faster and closer to their asking price: 26% of Cave Creek sales went under contract within 30 days, versus 17% in Carefree. At the slow end, 22% of Cave Creek sales took more than 120 days, versus 38% in Carefree, and in both towns those slow sales closed at about 86% to 87% of their original list price.

Supply is close to balanced in both, at about 4.7 months in Cave Creek and 4.5 in Carefree. Seller concessions showed up in 33% of Cave Creek sales (median $10,000 when offered) and 20% of Carefree sales (median $5,000).

What it means

If you want the widest choice of acreage, horse properties, and a range of price points, from a $626,500 median in Tatum Ranch to $1,150,000 for horse properties, Cave Creek simply has more inventory to look at. If you are focused on custom homes on desert lots, the golf at The Boulders and Desert Forest, or resort area properties, Carefree has a narrower but higher priced set of options, and sellers there have been taking longer to find buyers.

Practical steps for comparing the two

  • Check the jurisdiction, not just the mailing address. A Cave Creek address can be in the town, in Phoenix, or in unincorporated Maricopa County, and rules for permits, short-term rentals, and services follow the jurisdiction.
  • Compare price per square foot within the same community. Town wide medians mix horse properties, golf homes, and subdivision homes.
  • Read the days on market history. With 38% of Carefree sales taking more than 120 days, a long listed home may have room to negotiate.
  • Confirm the school district for the address with Cave Creek Unified or Deer Valley Unified directly.
  • Avoid this mistake: assuming a Carefree home is overpriced because the town median is higher. Compare it to recent sales of similar size and lot in the same area, since the price per square foot gap is far smaller than the median gap.

The honest caveats

Carefree's 133 sales are a small sample, so a handful of large or small sales can move its median. The Cave Creek figures cover every MLS sale with a Cave Creek address, including homes outside the town limits. Medians move with the mix of homes that sold, not just with values. Community figures above carry different as-of dates, and every number here will change as new sales close.

Frequently asked questions

Is Carefree more expensive than Cave Creek?

Yes, on the town wide numbers. Over the 12 months through November 16, 2026, the median sale with a Carefree address was $1,099,000 versus $870,000 with a Cave Creek address. The price per square foot gap is smaller, $388 versus $357.

How big are Cave Creek and Carefree?

Cave Creek covers about 37.71 square miles of land and Carefree about 8.81 square miles. 2025 Census estimates put their populations at about 5,160 and 3,600.

Which school districts serve Cave Creek and Carefree?

Carefree is served by Cave Creek Unified. Cave Creek is served by Cave Creek Unified and, in its western portion, Deer Valley Unified. Always confirm the district for a specific address with the district itself.

Do homes sell faster in Cave Creek or Carefree?

Cave Creek homes sold faster over the past 12 months, with a median of 61 cumulative days on market versus 98 in Carefree. About 26% of Cave Creek sales went under contract within 30 days, compared with 17% in Carefree.

What is the sales tax rate in Cave Creek and Carefree?

Both towns charge a 3.00% retail rate on top of the 6.30% state and Maricopa County rate, about 9.30% combined. On food for home consumption the town rate is 3.00% in Cave Creek and 2.00% in Carefree, per the Arizona Department of Revenue table effective November 1, 2026.

Is every Cave Creek address inside the Town of Cave Creek?

No. Many homes with a Cave Creek mailing address sit outside the town limits, including parts of the City of Phoenix and unincorporated county land. Check the jurisdiction for any home you are considering, because local rules follow it.

What kinds of homes are in Cave Creek?

Cave Creek is mostly custom homes on acreage, including horse properties, along with planned subdivisions such as Tatum Ranch. Prices range widely, from a $626,500 median in Tatum Ranch to $1,150,000 for horse properties over the past year.

What kinds of homes are in Carefree?

Carefree is mostly custom homes on desert lots, plus golf course and resort area properties such as those at The Boulders. About 56% of Carefree sales over the past 12 months closed at $1 million or more.

Are Cave Creek and Carefree buyer's or seller's markets right now?

Both are close to balanced, with about 4.7 months of supply in Cave Creek and 4.5 months in Carefree as of November 16, 2026. Sellers in Carefree have given up more ground, with homes closing at a median of 92.89% of their original list price versus 96.07% in Cave Creek.

How much have home prices changed in Cave Creek and Carefree over ten years?

The yearly median rose about 96% in both towns from 2016 to 2025. Cave Creek went from $420,000 to $825,000, and Carefree from $591,250 to $1,160,625.

The bottom line

Cave Creek and Carefree have grown in value at the same rate, but they are different markets. Cave Creek offers more homes, more land and horse property choices, and a faster pace. Carefree is smaller and higher priced, with longer marketing times that can give buyers more room. Compare homes community by community, not town by town, and verify the jurisdiction and school district for each address.

Read more: Cave Creek and Carefree property taxes: why your school district changes the bill · Cave Creek and Carefree golf communities: where listings sell and where they stall

Weighing Cave Creek against Carefree?

White-glove service at every price point.

Book a Call Get My Home Value

Browse homes: Cave Creek homes for sale · Carefree homes for sale · Cave Creek 85331 homes for sale · Carefree 85377 homes for sale

Related: Explore the Northeast Valley map · See our recently sold properties · More market insights

Your advisors

Kyle Hermann
Associate Broker | Realtor®
602.814.7266
kyle@azluxurypartners.com
License BR665419000
Meet Kyle

Cheryl Solano
CRS® | Realtor®
480.518.0181
cheryl@azluxurypartners.com
License SA541911000
Meet Cheryl

Art Buck
Associate Broker | Realtor® | CCIM
480.510.7689
art@azluxurypartners.com
License BR014102000
Meet Art

Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties

Sources

  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Cave Creek homes for sale page (ARMLS via Flexmls), as of November 16, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Carefree homes for sale page (ARMLS via Flexmls), as of November 16, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Cave Creek 85331 and Carefree 85377 ZIP pages, as of November 15, 2026. Link
  • Arizona Luxury Partners, Tatum Ranch (Nov 16, 2026), Cave Creek horse properties (Nov 14, 2026), The Boulders (Nov 6, 2026), and Desert Forest (Nov 16, 2026) pages. Link
  • Arizona Department of Revenue, TPT rate tables effective November 1, 2026. Link
  • Wikipedia, Carefree, Arizona (incorporation, land area, founding), checked November 16, 2026. Link
  • Wikipedia, Cave Creek, Arizona (settlement, incorporation, Black Mountain, school districts), checked November 16, 2026. Link
  • Differences calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: median gap $1,099,000 minus $870,000 = $229,000 (26.3%); price per square foot $388 minus $357 = $31 (8.7%); median size 2,799 minus 2,523 = 276 square feet (10.9%); land area 37.71 divided by 8.81 = 4.3; sales per month 614 and 133 divided by 12; combined sales tax 6.30% plus 3.00% = 9.30%.

All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This article is for general information only and is not financial, lending, legal, or tax advice. Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties, 21020 N. Pima Road, Scottsdale, AZ 85255. Brokerage License LC629808000. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Previous
Previous

Buying a home in Rio Verde Foothills: water, wells, and what to check in 2026

Next
Next

Scottsdale property taxes by school district: 2026 rates and what they cost