Your vision, your home, our expertise.
Over the past 12 months, about three of every four Windgate Ranch listings that left the market actually closed. In Desert Mountain and Troon North, the figure was closer to six in ten. That one number, the listing success rate, says a lot about how hard it is to sell in a given Scottsdale community, and it rarely gets discussed.
Among five north Scottsdale communities on our homes for sale pages, listing success rates ranged from 76% in Windgate Ranch to 63% in Troon North and Desert Mountain, against a citywide Scottsdale rate of 66% (figures as of October 31 to November 18, 2026). Higher rates came with shorter supply. Lower rates came with higher prices, longer days on market, or both.
What the data says
Every figure below comes from the market section of our own community pages, which use ARMLS data via Flexmls and cover the 12 months before each page's as of date. The success rate counts listings that closed versus those that were cancelled or expired.
- Windgate Ranch: 76% listing success (41 closed, 13 cancelled or expired), median sale $2,050,000, 71 cumulative days on market, 2.9 months of supply (ALP Windgate Ranch page, as of Nov 18, 2026)
- McDowell Mountain Ranch: 72% (176 closed, 67 cancelled or expired), median sale $1,109,500, 36 days on market, 2.8 months of supply (ALP McDowell Mountain Ranch page, as of Nov 12, 2026)
- Grayhawk: 67% (197 closed, 98 cancelled or expired), median sale $775,000, 57 days on market, 3.8 months of supply (ALP Grayhawk page, as of Nov 2, 2026)
- Troon North: 63% (100 closed, 59 cancelled or expired), median sale $1,280,000, 75.5 cumulative days on market, 4.7 months of supply (ALP Troon North page, as of Nov 18, 2026)
- Desert Mountain: 63% (165 closed, 99 cancelled or expired), median sale $2,700,000, 121 days on market, 6.4 months of supply (ALP Desert Mountain page, as of Nov 18, 2026)
- Benchmarks: Scottsdale citywide 66% (6,591 closed, 3,345 cancelled or expired, as of Nov 18, 2026); North Scottsdale 66% (2,157 closed, 1,093 cancelled or expired, as of Nov 12, 2026)
How the five communities compare
Windgate Ranch: the highest rate, on a small base
Windgate Ranch homes for sale sit near Bell Road at the base of the McDowell Mountains, in ZIP 85255. Only 10 homes were listed as of November 18, 2026, and supply was about 2.9 months, which the page describes as leaning toward sellers. The catch is in the price path: homes closed at a median of 95.7% of final list price but 92.6% of original list price. That 3.1 point gap, calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners, was the widest of the five, so many sellers did sell, but often after a reduction.
McDowell Mountain Ranch: fast and consistent
McDowell Mountain Ranch homes for sale posted a 72% success rate on 243 listings that left the market, the quickest median days on market here at 36, and the tightest supply at 2.8 months. Sale to original list was 96.08%, only 1.3 points under sale to final list. In plain terms, homes there tended to be priced close to what they sold for.
Grayhawk: right at the city average
Grayhawk homes for sale had the most activity of the group, with 197 closings, and a 67% success rate, almost exactly the citywide figure. Its median sale of $775,000 makes it the most attainable price point of the five, and the 1.5 point gap between original and final list price was modest.
Troon North and Desert Mountain: more listings come off unsold
Troon North homes for sale and Desert Mountain homes for sale both landed at 63%, the low end of this comparison. Desert Mountain is in ZIP 85262, as is the Troon North golf club, and our homes for sale in 85262 page showed 6.0 months of supply for that ZIP as of November 18, 2026, compared with 3.6 months on the Scottsdale 85255 homes for sale page. For every 10 closings in the past year, Desert Mountain had about 6.0 listings that were cancelled or expired, and Troon North about 5.9, versus about 3.2 in Windgate Ranch (calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners).
See where each of these communities sits on our Northeast Valley map, then compare them with the wider North Scottsdale homes for sale page and the citywide Scottsdale homes for sale and market data page.
What it means and why
The pattern is not complicated. Where supply is short and prices are closer to the middle of the market, most listings close. Where supply runs past five or six months and prices run into the millions, buyers have more choices and take more time, so more sellers withdraw, wait, or relist.
Price alone does not decide it, though. Windgate Ranch had the second highest median sale price in this group and the highest success rate. Low inventory did a lot of the work there. Desert Mountain, with 88 homes listed and 6.4 months of supply, had the opposite setup.
It also matters that a cancelled listing is not always a failed sale. Some sellers in seasonal markets pull a listing in summer and return in the fall. Under this measure, that counts as cancelled, which pushes the rate down in communities where that habit is common.
Practical steps for sellers
- Look up your own community's rate first. Each community page shows its success rate, closed count, and cancelled or expired count. Compare it with the 66% citywide figure so you know whether your market is easier or harder than average.
- Check the gap between original and final list price. A gap of three points or more, like Windgate Ranch, means many sellers started too high. A gap near one point, like McDowell Mountain Ranch, means first prices mostly held.
- Match your timeline to days on market. If your community's median is 121 days, as in Desert Mountain, plan for a longer runway and avoid listing with a deadline that forces a cut.
- Price from closings, not from neighbors' asking prices. Active listings include homes that will end up cancelled. Closed sales in your price band show what buyers actually paid.
- Avoid this mistake: pulling a listing after a few quiet weeks and relisting at the same price. It resets nothing for buyers who track the home, it counts as a cancellation, and the second launch rarely gets the attention of the first.
Practical steps for buyers
- Read a low success rate as room to negotiate. In communities where many listings come off unsold, sellers who stay on the market are often more open to terms.
- Move quickly where supply is tight. In McDowell Mountain Ranch, 36 median days on market and 2.8 months of supply suggest less time to decide.
- Watch for relisted homes. A home that was cancelled and relisted may carry a reset day count on some sites. Ask your agent for the full listing history.
The honest caveats
- Small samples swing. Windgate Ranch's 76% rests on 54 listings that left the market. A handful of different outcomes would move it several points.
- Dates differ. The pages were updated on different days, from October 31 to November 18, 2026, so the five 12 month windows do not line up exactly.
- Definitions differ slightly. Some pages report cumulative days on market and others report days on market, and each page defines its community by MLS subdivision and ZIP as explained in its FAQ.
- Averages hide price bands. A community's overall rate can differ a lot from the rate for homes at your price point or with your lot and view.
- Past results do not predict the next listing. Pricing, condition, and timing still decide individual outcomes.
Frequently asked questions
What is a listing success rate?
A listing success rate is the share of listings that left the market over a set period and closed, rather than being cancelled or expiring. On our community pages it covers the past 12 months. A listing that was cancelled and then relisted counts as cancelled, so the rate captures homes that had to be pulled and tried again.
What is a good listing success rate in Scottsdale?
As of November 18, 2026, our Scottsdale page shows a citywide listing success rate of 66% over the past 12 months, and North Scottsdale shows 66% as of November 12, 2026. A community well above that, like Windgate Ranch at 76%, has had fewer failed listings than the city as a whole. A community in the low 60s is not failing; it simply has more listings that came off without selling.
Which Scottsdale community in this comparison has the highest listing success rate?
Of the five communities compared here, Windgate Ranch had the highest rate at 76%, with 41 closings and 13 cancelled or expired listings in the 12 months to November 18, 2026. Keep in mind that is a small sample. McDowell Mountain Ranch was next at 72% on a much larger base of 243 listings that left the market.
Why is the listing success rate lower in Desert Mountain?
Desert Mountain showed a 63% listing success rate, 121 median days on market, and 6.4 months of supply as of November 18, 2026. Homes there sold at a median of $2,700,000, and higher price points often take longer and see more listings withdrawn and retried. Sellers also may pull a listing for the summer and return in the fall, which counts as cancelled.
Does a cancelled listing mean the home did not sell?
Not always. A seller may cancel to change agents, reprice, update photos, or wait for a better season, and the home may sell later under a new listing. That is why a cancelled and relisted home counts as cancelled in this measure, and why the rate is best read alongside days on market and price changes.
How is the listing success rate different from the sale to list price ratio?
The success rate tells you how many listings closed at all. The sale to list ratio tells you how close the closed homes came to their asking price. A community can have a high success rate and still show sizable price cuts, which you see when the sale to original list price is well below the sale to final list price.
What does months of supply mean for a Scottsdale seller?
Months of supply is the number of homes for sale divided by the average number of sales per month. Lower numbers point to a market leaning toward sellers; higher numbers point toward buyers. In this comparison it ranged from 2.8 months in McDowell Mountain Ranch to 6.4 months in Desert Mountain.
How can I improve my chances of selling a Scottsdale home on the first listing?
Price from recent closed sales in your own community and price band rather than from active listings, since the gap between original and final list price shows how often first prices were too high. Prepare the home before it goes live, because the first weeks bring the most attention. Ask your agent for the success rate and days on market for homes like yours, not just the community average.
Are these listing success rates the same as what Zillow or Redfin shows?
No. These figures come from ARMLS data via Flexmls as calculated on our own community pages, with each page stating its period and how it defines the community. Other sites use different data, boundaries, and definitions, so their numbers will not match exactly. Compare figures from one source at a time.
How often are the community page figures updated?
Each community page shows its own as of date. In this post the dates range from October 31, 2026 to November 18, 2026, and each figure covers the 12 months before that date. Check the page itself for the latest numbers before making a decision.
The bottom line
Listing success rates in these five north Scottsdale communities ran from 63% to 76% over the past year, around a citywide 66%. Short supply and realistic first prices went with higher rates; long days on market and deep inventory went with lower ones. Before you list or make an offer, look up the rate, the price gap, and the supply for your own community, then plan your pricing and timeline around them.
Read more: Seller concessions in Scottsdale: how often sellers pay buyer costs, by ZIP code · Desert Ridge listing success rates: which neighborhoods sell and which stall
Thinking about selling in Scottsdale?
White-glove service at every price point.
Book a Call Get My Home ValueBrowse homes: North Scottsdale homes for sale · Scottsdale 85255 homes for sale · McDowell Mountain Ranch homes for sale · Windgate Ranch homes for sale
Related: Explore the Northeast Valley map · See our recently sold properties · More market insights
Your advisors
Kyle Hermann
Associate Broker | Realtor®
602.814.7266
kyle@azluxurypartners.com
License BR665419000
Meet Kyle
Cheryl Solano
CRS® | Realtor®
480.518.0181
cheryl@azluxurypartners.com
License SA541911000
Meet Cheryl
Art Buck
Associate Broker | Realtor® | CCIM
480.510.7689
art@azluxurypartners.com
License BR014102000
Meet Art
Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties
Sources
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Windgate Ranch homes for sale, market figures as of November 18, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, McDowell Mountain Ranch homes for sale, market figures as of November 12, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Grayhawk homes for sale, market figures as of November 2, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Troon North homes for sale, market figures as of November 18, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Desert Mountain homes for sale, market figures as of November 18, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Scottsdale homes for sale, citywide market figures as of November 18, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, North Scottsdale homes for sale, market figures as of November 12, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Scottsdale 85255 and 85262 homes for sale, months of supply as of November 18, 2026 (ARMLS via Flexmls). Link
- Cancelled or expired listings per 10 closings calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: cancelled or expired count divided by closed count, times 10 (Windgate Ranch 13 and 41, Troon North 59 and 100, Desert Mountain 99 and 165).
- Gap between sale to final list and sale to original list calculated by Arizona Luxury Partners: Windgate Ranch 95.7% minus 92.6%, McDowell Mountain Ranch 97.38% minus 96.08%, Grayhawk 97.6% minus 96.1%.
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This article is for general information only and is not financial, lending, legal, or tax advice. Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties, 21020 N. Pima Road, Scottsdale, AZ 85255. Brokerage License LC629808000. Equal Housing Opportunity.