Your vision, your home, our expertise.
Paradise Valley and Arcadia sit a few miles apart at the foot of Camelback Mountain, and buyers shopping one almost always look at the other. On paper they read as two different markets. Over the past 12 months the median home in Paradise Valley sold for $3,800,000, while the median in Arcadia sold for $1,621,300, less than half. But the heart of Arcadia tells a different story: homes in Arcadia Proper, the large lot core east of 44th Street, sold at a median of $3,600,000, almost even with Paradise Valley. Here is how the two stack up on price, pace, and supply, using current MLS figures.
Paradise Valley and Arcadia, side by side
These figures come from closed and active MLS data on our own homes for sale pages, each read on the date shown. Paradise Valley is an incorporated town; Arcadia is a neighborhood whose core sits in east Phoenix with its eastern edge in Scottsdale. See both on our Northeast Valley map.
- Median sale price, past 12 months: Paradise Valley $3,800,000; Arcadia $1,621,300 (ARMLS via Flexmls, PV through Nov 12 2026, Arcadia through Nov 6 2026)
- Median price per square foot: Paradise Valley $847; Arcadia $588 (same source)
- Median days on market: Paradise Valley 62; Arcadia 59 (same source)
- Months of supply: Paradise Valley 6.8; Arcadia 3.8 (same source)
- Homes for sale today: Paradise Valley 233; Arcadia 126 (same source)
- Median list price of active homes: Paradise Valley $5,322,500; Arcadia $1,519,500 (same source)
- Listing success rate, past 12 months: Paradise Valley 52%; Arcadia 63% (same source)
- Median home size sold: Paradise Valley 4,363 square feet; Arcadia 2,827 square feet (same source)
What the price gap really measures
The headline difference, $3,800,000 against $1,621,300, is partly a size and lot story rather than a pure value gap. The typical Paradise Valley home that sold was 4,363 square feet; the typical Arcadia home was 2,827 square feet. Paradise Valley is built on large lots across an incorporated town, and in Paradise Valley homes for sale you are usually buying more land. Arcadia ranges from condos and smaller citrus era lots in Arcadia Lite up to half acre and larger parcels in Arcadia Proper.
On a price per square foot basis the gap is smaller: $847 in Paradise Valley against $588 across Arcadia. And within Arcadia, the core runs higher than the town next door. Arcadia Proper sold at $867 per square foot, above Paradise Valley, with a median sale price of $3,600,000 over the past 12 months. So a buyer who wants Camelback Mountain views and a large lot can end up paying similar money in either place, while a buyer open to a smaller lot in Arcadia homes for sale can enter the area for far less.
Supply and pace: who holds the leverage
Paradise Valley carries more standing inventory relative to how fast it sells. Its 233 active listings work out to about 6.8 months of supply, which leans toward buyers. Arcadia's 126 active listings are about 3.8 months of supply, closer to a balanced market. Days on market are close, 62 in Paradise Valley and 59 in Arcadia, but the deeper inventory in Paradise Valley gives buyers more to choose from and more room to negotiate.
Negotiation shows up in how far homes drift from list price. In Paradise Valley, homes closed at a median of 96% of final list price and 93.14% of original list price, so the typical home sold about 7% under where it started. In Arcadia, homes closed at 96.37% of final and 93.64% of original. Seller concessions were slightly more common in Arcadia, 24% of sales, than in Paradise Valley, 14%, with median concessions of $12,000 and $15,000 respectively on the sales that had one.
The first 30 days decide a lot
Pricing right at the start pays in both markets. In Paradise Valley, 126 of last year's sales, 31%, went under contract within 30 days at about 97% of list price on average, while 110 sales, 27%, took more than 120 days and closed at about 86% of their original list price. In Arcadia, 117 sales, 29%, went under contract within 30 days at about 98% of list price, and 77 sales, 19%, took more than 120 days and closed at about 86% of original list. The pattern is the same in both: homes that sell fast sell close to ask, and homes that linger give it back.
Listing success rate: Arcadia finishes more often
Listing success rate is the share of listings that left the market over the past 12 months that closed rather than being cancelled or expiring. Arcadia came in at 63%, with 399 listings closing against 236 that cancelled or expired. Paradise Valley came in at 52%, with 409 closing against 377 cancelling or expiring. The lower rate in Paradise Valley fits its higher price point and deeper supply: at the top of the market, more sellers test a number, do not get it, and pull the listing.
How prices have moved over 10 years
Both areas have climbed hard. The median sale price in Paradise Valley went from $1,177,500 in 2016 to $3,550,000 in 2025, up 201%, and the year to date median through November 12, 2026 is $3,971,000. Arcadia went from $515,500 in 2016 to $1,350,000 in 2025, up 162%, with a year to date median of $1,700,000. Arcadia Proper, the core, went from $1,150,000 to $2,675,000 over the same period and sits at a $3,525,000 median so far this year. A median is the middle sale of the year, so it moves with both prices and the mix of homes that sold, not only with values.
A second read on Paradise Valley
MLS figures are not the only source. Redfin, using its own ZIP code data, reported a median sale price of about $3,348,284 in ZIP 85253 over the three months ending October 2026, up 2.7% from a year earlier, with 83 homes sold in October and a median of 77 days on market. Redfin and the MLS draw their boundaries and time windows differently, so the two will not match exactly, but both point to a Paradise Valley market in the low to mid $3 million range and holding steady rather than spiking.
The honest caveats
These are medians across whole areas, and they hide a lot. Paradise Valley sales run from under $1 million to well over $10 million, so a single median tells you little about any one street. Arcadia is really three or four submarkets stacked together: Lower Arcadia near $1,250,000, Arcadia Lite near $980,000, and Arcadia Proper near $3,600,000. The two areas were also measured a few days apart, Paradise Valley through November 12 and Arcadia through November 6, so do not read small differences as precise. Boundaries matter too: Arcadia has no official line, and homes just outside the Phoenix 85018 core can carry a different price. For any specific home, compare it against recent sales on its own block and of its own type, not against an area wide median.
Frequently asked questions
Is Paradise Valley or Arcadia more expensive?
Paradise Valley is more expensive overall. Over the past 12 months its median sale price was $3,800,000 against $1,621,300 in Arcadia. The gap narrows at the top of Arcadia: Arcadia Proper, the large lot core, had a median of $3,600,000, close to Paradise Valley. Price per square foot was $847 in Paradise Valley and $588 across Arcadia.
Why does Paradise Valley cost so much more than Arcadia overall?
Much of the gap is size and lot. The typical Paradise Valley home that sold was 4,363 square feet, against 2,827 square feet in Arcadia, and Paradise Valley sits on large lots across an incorporated town. On a price per square foot basis the difference is smaller, and Arcadia Proper actually sold higher per foot than Paradise Valley at $867.
Which market favors buyers right now?
Paradise Valley leans more toward buyers. It had about 6.8 months of supply with 233 active listings as of November 12, 2026, while Arcadia had about 3.8 months with 126 listings as of November 6, 2026. More standing inventory in Paradise Valley gives buyers more choice and more room to negotiate.
How fast do homes sell in each area?
Pace is similar. The median days on market was 62 in Paradise Valley and 59 in Arcadia over the past 12 months. In both areas, homes that went under contract within 30 days sold at about 97% to 98% of list price, while homes that sat past 120 days closed near 86% of their original list price.
What is the difference between Arcadia Proper, Arcadia Lite, and Lower Arcadia?
They are informal market names, not official boundaries. Arcadia Proper is the large lot core east of 44th Street and sold at a median of $3,600,000. Arcadia Lite to the west sold near $980,000, and Lower Arcadia to the south sold near $1,250,000. Lot size and age of home vary widely among them.
Is Arcadia in Paradise Valley?
No. Arcadia is a neighborhood whose core lies in east Phoenix, with its eastern edge in Scottsdale. Paradise Valley is a separate incorporated town to the north. They sit a few miles apart near Camelback Mountain, which is why buyers often compare them.
How much have prices risen in Paradise Valley and Arcadia?
Both climbed sharply over 10 years. Paradise Valley went from a $1,177,500 median in 2016 to $3,550,000 in 2025, up 201%. Arcadia went from $515,500 to $1,350,000, up 162%. Year to date in 2026, the medians are about $3,971,000 in Paradise Valley and $1,700,000 in Arcadia.
Which area has a higher listing success rate?
Arcadia, at 63%, against 52% in Paradise Valley over the past 12 months. Listing success rate is the share of listings that left the market that closed rather than being cancelled or expiring. The lower rate in Paradise Valley fits its higher price point and deeper supply.
Are seller concessions common in either market?
They happen more in Arcadia. About 24% of Arcadia sales included a seller paid buyer cost, such as closing costs or a rate buydown, against 14% in Paradise Valley. The median concession on sales that had one was $12,000 in Arcadia and $15,000 in Paradise Valley.
Can I get a Camelback Mountain area home for under $1 million?
It is possible in parts of Arcadia but rare in Paradise Valley. Arcadia Lite sold at a median near $980,000, and only about 49% of its sales closed at $1 million or more, so entry level options exist there. In Paradise Valley, 88% of sales closed at $1 million or more, so sub million dollar homes are uncommon.
The bottom line
Paradise Valley and Arcadia are not really one versus the other. Paradise Valley is the larger lot, higher price, deeper supply market where buyers hold more leverage. Arcadia is a set of submarkets, from entry level in Arcadia Lite to Paradise Valley pricing in Arcadia Proper, that sells a bit faster and finishes more listings. If you want land and a town address, Paradise Valley is the comparison. If you want flexibility on price and a tighter market, Arcadia gives you more ways in. We can pull the exact recent sales that fit your search in either area and show you how a specific home compares.
Read more: Paradise Valley home prices: 10 years of sales and where the market stands now and Clearwater Hills in Paradise Valley: the guard gate, county island lots, and home prices
Comparing Paradise Valley and Arcadia?
White-glove service at every price point.
Book a Call Get My Home ValueBrowse homes: Paradise Valley homes for sale · Arcadia Proper homes for sale · Paradise Valley 85253 homes for sale · Arcadia homes for sale
Related: Explore the Northeast Valley map · See our recently sold properties · Search homes for sale · More market insights
Your advisors
Kyle Hermann
Associate Broker | Realtor®
602.814.7266
kyle@azluxurypartners.com
License BR665419000
Meet Kyle
Cheryl Solano
CRS® | Realtor®
480.518.0181
cheryl@azluxurypartners.com
License SA541911000
Meet Cheryl
Art Buck
Associate Broker | Realtor® | CCIM
480.510.7689
art@azluxurypartners.com
License BR014102000
Meet Art
Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties
Sources
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Paradise Valley homes for sale market data (ARMLS via Flexmls), closed and active residential sales through November 12, 2026. Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Arcadia homes for sale market data (ARMLS via Flexmls), closed and active residential sales through November 6, 2026. Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Arcadia Proper homes for sale market data (ARMLS via Flexmls), through November 6, 2026. Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Arcadia Lite and Lower Arcadia homes for sale market data (ARMLS via Flexmls), through November 6, 2026. Link
- Arizona Luxury Partners, Paradise Valley 85253 homes for sale market data (ARMLS via Flexmls), through November 11, 2026. Link
- Redfin, 85253 housing market, median sale price for the three months ending October 2026, accessed November 13, 2026. Link
All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This article is for general information only and is not financial, lending, legal, or tax advice. Arizona Luxury Partners | Real Estate Group at RE/MAX Fine Properties, 21020 N. Pima Road, Scottsdale, AZ 85255. Brokerage License LC629808000. Equal Housing Opportunity.
